7 Key Factors to Choose the Bester Neobroker for Your Investment Needs

Video: Bester Neobroker 2026? Trade Republic vs Scalable vs Trading 212 (+ zero & Smartbroker+)
· based on the channel Geldaura
Key takeaways
- Trade Republic offers zero commission on orders from 1,000 euros upwards
- Scalable Capital provides the largest selection of ETF savings plans
- Trading 212 supports real cryptocurrencies trading
- PFOF ban since July 2026 impacts trading venues and fees
- Smartbroker+ offers competitive interest rates on cash balances
Choosing the bester neobroker depends on your trading volume, investment preferences, and desired features. Trade Republic, Scalable Capital, Trading 212, finanzen.net zero, and Smartbroker+ lead the market with distinct strengths in fees, savings plans, interest rates, and crypto offerings. For a detailed side-by-side comparison and up-to-date conditions, visit Geldaura's best online brokers comparison.
1. Order Fees and Cost Efficiency
Order fees vary significantly among neobrokers, especially after the PFOF (Payment for Order Flow) ban in July 2026, which reshaped fee structures and trading venues. Trade Republic charges zero commission on orders of 1,000 euros and above, making it very cost-effective for medium-to-large trades. In contrast, smaller orders may incur minor fees or surcharges at some brokers. Scalable Capital offers a transparent subscription model alongside free orders depending on the plan, while Trading 212 maintains zero-commission trading but with some limitations on order sizes and execution venues.
2. ETF Savings Plans Availability
For investors focused on long-term wealth building through ETFs, the number of available ETF savings plans is crucial. Scalable Capital stands out by offering the largest selection of ETF savings plans, enabling diversified portfolio construction. Trade Republic and finanzen.net zero also provide extensive ETF options, though with slightly fewer choices. Smartbroker+ supports savings plans but with more limited ETF options. Understanding your preferred ETFs and whether they are covered by the broker’s savings plan offering is essential.
3. Interest on Cash Balances
Post-PFOF, brokers have adjusted how they handle client cash balances. Smartbroker+ leads in offering attractive interest rates on cash, but these rates may depend on where the money is held (e.g., segregated accounts or partner banks). Trade Republic and Scalable Capital offer modest interest but tend to keep client funds in low-risk deposits. It’s important to check exact terms, as some brokers require minimum balances or specific account types to qualify for interest.
4. Trading Venues and Impact of PFOF Ban
The PFOF ban in July 2026 significantly affected trading venues and pricing. Brokers that previously relied on PFOF now route orders predominantly through Xetra or other regulated exchanges, impacting execution prices and liquidity. Trade Republic and Scalable Capital have adapted by integrating multiple trading venues and focusing on transparent pricing. Trading 212, originally UK-based, adjusted its order routing to comply with EU regulations. This change benefits investors by potentially improving price fairness but may affect execution speed and costs.
5. Cryptocurrency Offerings
If you want to include cryptocurrencies in your portfolio, Trading 212 stands out by offering real crypto asset trading, not just CFDs or derivatives. Trade Republic also provides crypto trading but with a more limited selection. Scalable Capital, finanzen.net zero, and Smartbroker+ generally do not focus on crypto assets. Consider your appetite for crypto exposure and whether you prefer direct ownership or derivative products.
6. Taxation and Security Checks
All brokers comply with German tax reporting standards, offering automatic tax statements to simplify filing. Security of deposits is ensured through regulatory mandates and investor compensation schemes, but coverage limits vary. Trade Republic and Scalable Capital hold client assets separately and offer robust encryption and authentication. Always verify the broker’s safety measures and tax support features before committing.
7. Which Neobroker Fits Your Profile?
Your ideal neobroker depends on your investment profile:
- For cost-conscious traders placing orders over 1,000 euros, Trade Republic is highly recommended.
- If you prioritize a wide ETF savings plan selection, Scalable Capital is the best choice.
- For crypto enthusiasts wanting direct crypto trading, Trading 212 is preferable.
- If you want attractive cash interest rates, consider Smartbroker+.
- Finanzen.net zero is a balanced option with moderate fees and features.
Useful Links
- Best Online Brokers Comparison by Geldaura: https://geldaura.com/vergleiche/beste-online-broker-2026/
- Geldaura Homepage for more independent financial and broker tests: https://geldaura.com/
Conclusion
The quest for the bester neobroker hinges on balancing fees, available products, interest on cash, and trading features. Trade Republic, Scalable Capital, Trading 212, finanzen.net zero, and Smartbroker+ each serve specific investor needs post-PFOF ban. For the most current and detailed comparison, consult Geldaura’s comprehensive broker tests and rankings. This independent analysis helps investors choose the platform that fits their profile and investment goals most effectively.
Questions & answers
What impact did the PFOF ban have on neobrokers?
The PFOF ban ended brokers' practice of receiving payments for order flow, leading to more transparent order routing through regulated exchanges like Xetra. This improved pricing fairness but changed fee structures and execution venues.
Which neobroker offers the largest selection of ETF savings plans?
Scalable Capital provides the widest range of ETF savings plans, allowing investors to build diversified portfolios with many ETF options.
Do all neobrokers support real cryptocurrency trading?
No, only some neobrokers like Trading 212 offer real crypto asset trading. Others, such as Trade Republic, provide limited crypto options, while some don't support crypto at all.
How do brokers handle interest on cash balances after the PFOF ban?
Interest rates on cash vary by broker. Smartbroker+ offers the highest interest but may require funds to be held in specific accounts. Trade Republic and Scalable Capital provide modest interest rates, focusing on safe, low-risk deposits.
Source: Bester Neobroker 2026? Trade Republic vs Scalable vs Trading 212 (+ zero & Smartbroker+) · Markdown version